Why did the Painted Bunting come to Brooklyn?

It has been an exciting week in the New York City bird scene (yes, that’s totally a thing).  On Sunday, Keir Randall spotted a Painted Bunting (PB) in Prospect Park in Brooklyn. Word quickly got around and local birders were all aflutter. Now, with mentions in the New York Times, the Gothamist, and Fox and CBS news crews on the scene today, the bird is only going to get more attention.

The bird is gorgeous.

Photo: Jean Shum
Photo: Jean Shum

It’s fitting that it’s name in French, Passerin nonpareil, literally means “Cardinal without equal” (it is technically a member of the Cardinal family).

Its blended colors instantly reminded us of a slightly melted snow cone:

PB and snowcone2
Compare and contrast: Painted Bunting, Yummy snow cone

And it is exceedingly rare in these parts. According to the New York Post: “This is the first adult male Painted Bunting that’s ever had a recorded visit to Brooklyn — and one of only 10 birds of his species to have arrived in NYC since 1927, according to data compiled by the New York State Avian Records Committee.”

For a lot of people who can’t travel to its normal habitat range (southern states, Mexico, the Caribbean, and Central America), this is their one chance to see it. As a result, people are reportedly coming from as far as Maryland to catch a glimpse. 

So why has this beauty breezed into Brooklyn?  Here are three possibilities:

  1. It doesn’t want to be caged.

    Unfortunately, because Painted Buntings are so beautiful they “are captured both on their Florida breeding grounds and on their wintering grounds in the Caribbean, Mexico, and Central America. Trappers take only the showy adult males, skewing the sex and age ratios in the population as well as reducing overall numbers.” (from an article from All About Birds , which is run by the Cornell Lab of Ornithology).  Perhaps the little guy is sick of running!

  2. It came to see its Latin “namesake”, Keir, the birder who first saw it here.

    PB’s Latin name, Passerina ciris (or keiris in Greek), was given to the bird by Linnaeus due to a Greek myth related to its violet/blue head, according to the book, “One Hundred Birds and how they got their names” by Diana Wells.

    The story goes: A woman, Scylla, who drowned and was turned into a seabird named “Keiris” after she betrayed her father by stealing a lock of his magical purple hair. So it is a coincidence that Keir Randall of Brooklyn happened to be the first one to spot the Passerina keiris?  Only those two might know.

  3. It believed the hype.


Perhaps the PB caught a strong wind that blew it off of its normal migration route…it saw the “Welcome to Brooklyn” sign and was intrigued. 


Whatever the truth, we’re glad that it decided to visit.  If you’d like to see it for yourself, check out the New York ABA Birding News for the latest updates.

Thank you to Jean Shum for the photos and info.

4 thoughts on “Why did the Painted Bunting come to Brooklyn?”

  1. Oh, so very gorgeous! I’d like to think he’s there because of #3, but honestly think it’s more like #1. Did he maybe escape from a cage in someone’s home? (Do people purchase these birds a pets somewhere? But, that would be illegal, no?! ) Anyway I hope he has his freedom ad a long and happy bird life.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Thank you! It is illegal to trap and/or trade them and the good news is that it seems to actually be a wild bird.
    Local birders were wondering the same thing and asked Paul Sweet, from the Department of Ornithology at the American Museum of Natural History. His reply was, “Everything looks great for a wild bird. Feathers, claws etc show no sign of being in a cage. Also dates perfect for vagrant Painted Bunting.” The conversation is here.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s